diff --git a/index-scheduler/src/autobatcher.rs b/index-scheduler/src/autobatcher.rs
index 31634237f..24625a7fb 100644
--- a/index-scheduler/src/autobatcher.rs
+++ b/index-scheduler/src/autobatcher.rs
@@ -311,18 +311,9 @@ impl BatchKind {
                 })
             }
             (
-                BatchKind::DocumentOperation { method, allow_index_creation, primary_key, mut operation_ids },
+                this @ BatchKind::DocumentOperation { .. },
                 K::DocumentDeletion,
-            ) => {
-                operation_ids.push(id);
-
-                Continue(BatchKind::DocumentOperation {
-                    method,
-                    allow_index_creation,
-                    primary_key,
-                    operation_ids,
-                })
-            }
+            ) => Break(this),
             // but we can't autobatch documents if it's not the same kind
             // this match branch MUST be AFTER the previous one
             (
@@ -345,35 +336,7 @@ impl BatchKind {
                 deletion_ids.push(id);
                 Continue(BatchKind::DocumentClear { ids: deletion_ids })
             }
-            // we can autobatch the deletion and import if the index already exists
-            (
-                BatchKind::DocumentDeletion { mut deletion_ids },
-                K::DocumentImport { method, allow_index_creation, primary_key }
-            ) if index_already_exists => {
-                deletion_ids.push(id);
-
-                Continue(BatchKind::DocumentOperation {
-                    method,
-                    allow_index_creation,
-                    primary_key,
-                    operation_ids: deletion_ids,
-                })
-            }
-            // we can autobatch the deletion and import if both can't create an index
-            (
-                BatchKind::DocumentDeletion { mut deletion_ids },
-                K::DocumentImport { method, allow_index_creation, primary_key }
-            ) if !allow_index_creation => {
-                deletion_ids.push(id);
-
-                Continue(BatchKind::DocumentOperation {
-                    method,
-                    allow_index_creation,
-                    primary_key,
-                    operation_ids: deletion_ids,
-                })
-            }
-            // we can't autobatch a deletion and an import if the index does not exists but would be created by an addition
+            // we can't autobatch a deletion and an import
             (
                 this @ BatchKind::DocumentDeletion { .. },
                 K::DocumentImport { .. }
@@ -674,36 +637,36 @@ mod tests {
         debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false,None,  [settings(false)]), @"Some((Settings { allow_index_creation: false, settings_ids: [0] }, false))");
         debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false,None,  [settings(false), settings(false), settings(false)]), @"Some((Settings { allow_index_creation: false, settings_ids: [0, 1, 2] }, false))");
 
-        // We can autobatch document addition with document deletion
-        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, true, None), doc_del()]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: true, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0, 1] }, true))");
-        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, true, None), doc_del()]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: true, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0, 1] }, true))");
-        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, false, None), doc_del()]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0, 1] }, false))");
-        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, false, None), doc_del()]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0, 1] }, false))");
-        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, true, Some("catto")), doc_del()]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: true, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0, 1] }, true))"###);
-        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, true, Some("catto")), doc_del()]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: true, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0, 1] }, true))"###);
-        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, false, Some("catto")), doc_del()]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0, 1] }, false))"###);
-        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, false, Some("catto")), doc_del()]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0, 1] }, false))"###);
-        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, true, None), doc_del()]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: true, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0, 1] }, true))");
-        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, true, None), doc_del()]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: true, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0, 1] }, true))");
-        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, false, None), doc_del()]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0, 1] }, false))");
-        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, false, None), doc_del()]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0, 1] }, false))");
-        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, true, Some("catto")), doc_del()]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: true, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0, 1] }, true))"###);
-        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, true, Some("catto")), doc_del()]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: true, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0, 1] }, true))"###);
-        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, false, Some("catto")), doc_del()]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0, 1] }, false))"###);
-        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, false, Some("catto")), doc_del()]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0, 1] }, false))"###);
-        // And the other way around
-        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, true, None)]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: true, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0, 1] }, false))");
-        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, true, None)]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: true, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0, 1] }, false))");
-        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, false, None)]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0, 1] }, false))");
-        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, false, None)]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0, 1] }, false))");
-        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, true, Some("catto"))]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: true, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0, 1] }, false))"###);
-        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, true, Some("catto"))]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: true, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0, 1] }, false))"###);
-        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, false, Some("catto"))]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0, 1] }, false))"###);
-        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, false, Some("catto"))]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0, 1] }, false))"###);
-        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, false, None)]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0, 1] }, false))");
-        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, false, None)]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0, 1] }, false))");
-        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, false, Some("catto"))]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0, 1] }, false))"###);
-        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, false, Some("catto"))]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0, 1] }, false))"###);
+        // We can't autobatch document addition with document deletion
+        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, true, None), doc_del()]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: true, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0] }, true))");
+        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, true, None), doc_del()]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: true, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0] }, true))");
+        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, false, None), doc_del()]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0] }, false))");
+        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, false, None), doc_del()]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0] }, false))");
+        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, true, Some("catto")), doc_del()]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: true, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0] }, true))"###);
+        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, true, Some("catto")), doc_del()]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: true, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0] }, true))"###);
+        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, false, Some("catto")), doc_del()]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0] }, false))"###);
+        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, false, Some("catto")), doc_del()]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0] }, false))"###);
+        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, true, None), doc_del()]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: true, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0] }, true))");
+        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, true, None), doc_del()]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: true, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0] }, true))");
+        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, false, None), doc_del()]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0] }, false))");
+        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, false, None), doc_del()]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0] }, false))");
+        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, true, Some("catto")), doc_del()]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: true, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0] }, true))"###);
+        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, true, Some("catto")), doc_del()]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: true, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0] }, true))"###);
+        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, false, Some("catto")), doc_del()]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0] }, false))"###);
+        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, false, Some("catto")), doc_del()]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0] }, false))"###);
+        // we also can't do the only way around
+        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, true, None)]), @"Some((DocumentDeletion { deletion_ids: [0] }, false))");
+        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, true, None)]), @"Some((DocumentDeletion { deletion_ids: [0] }, false))");
+        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, false, None)]), @"Some((DocumentDeletion { deletion_ids: [0] }, false))");
+        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, false, None)]), @"Some((DocumentDeletion { deletion_ids: [0] }, false))");
+        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, true, Some("catto"))]), @"Some((DocumentDeletion { deletion_ids: [0] }, false))");
+        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, true, Some("catto"))]), @"Some((DocumentDeletion { deletion_ids: [0] }, false))");
+        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, false, Some("catto"))]), @"Some((DocumentDeletion { deletion_ids: [0] }, false))");
+        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, false, Some("catto"))]), @"Some((DocumentDeletion { deletion_ids: [0] }, false))");
+        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, false, None)]), @"Some((DocumentDeletion { deletion_ids: [0] }, false))");
+        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, false, None)]), @"Some((DocumentDeletion { deletion_ids: [0] }, false))");
+        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, false, Some("catto"))]), @"Some((DocumentDeletion { deletion_ids: [0] }, false))");
+        debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, false, Some("catto"))]), @"Some((DocumentDeletion { deletion_ids: [0] }, false))");
     }
 
     #[test]
diff --git a/index-scheduler/src/lib.rs b/index-scheduler/src/lib.rs
index b402985e3..0f82fb47d 100644
--- a/index-scheduler/src/lib.rs
+++ b/index-scheduler/src/lib.rs
@@ -1869,105 +1869,6 @@ mod tests {
         snapshot!(snapshot_index_scheduler(&index_scheduler), name: "both_task_succeeded");
     }
 
-    #[test]
-    fn document_addition_and_document_deletion() {
-        let (index_scheduler, mut handle) = IndexScheduler::test(true, vec![]);
-
-        let content = r#"[
-            { "id": 1, "doggo": "jean bob" },
-            { "id": 2, "catto": "jorts" },
-            { "id": 3, "doggo": "bork" }
-        ]"#;
-
-        let (uuid, mut file) = index_scheduler.create_update_file_with_uuid(0).unwrap();
-        let documents_count = read_json(content.as_bytes(), file.as_file_mut()).unwrap();
-        file.persist().unwrap();
-        index_scheduler
-            .register(KindWithContent::DocumentAdditionOrUpdate {
-                index_uid: S("doggos"),
-                primary_key: Some(S("id")),
-                method: ReplaceDocuments,
-                content_file: uuid,
-                documents_count,
-                allow_index_creation: true,
-            })
-            .unwrap();
-        snapshot!(snapshot_index_scheduler(&index_scheduler), name: "registered_the_first_task");
-        index_scheduler
-            .register(KindWithContent::DocumentDeletion {
-                index_uid: S("doggos"),
-                documents_ids: vec![S("1"), S("2")],
-            })
-            .unwrap();
-        snapshot!(snapshot_index_scheduler(&index_scheduler), name: "registered_the_second_task");
-
-        handle.advance_one_successful_batch(); // The addition AND deletion should've been batched together
-        snapshot!(snapshot_index_scheduler(&index_scheduler), name: "after_processing_the_batch");
-
-        let index = index_scheduler.index("doggos").unwrap();
-        let rtxn = index.read_txn().unwrap();
-        let field_ids_map = index.fields_ids_map(&rtxn).unwrap();
-        let field_ids = field_ids_map.ids().collect::<Vec<_>>();
-        let documents = index
-            .all_documents(&rtxn)
-            .unwrap()
-            .map(|ret| obkv_to_json(&field_ids, &field_ids_map, ret.unwrap().1).unwrap())
-            .collect::<Vec<_>>();
-        snapshot!(serde_json::to_string_pretty(&documents).unwrap(), name: "documents");
-    }
-
-    #[test]
-    fn document_deletion_and_document_addition() {
-        let (index_scheduler, mut handle) = IndexScheduler::test(true, vec![]);
-        index_scheduler
-            .register(KindWithContent::DocumentDeletion {
-                index_uid: S("doggos"),
-                documents_ids: vec![S("1"), S("2")],
-            })
-            .unwrap();
-        snapshot!(snapshot_index_scheduler(&index_scheduler), name: "registered_the_first_task");
-
-        let content = r#"[
-            { "id": 1, "doggo": "jean bob" },
-            { "id": 2, "catto": "jorts" },
-            { "id": 3, "doggo": "bork" }
-        ]"#;
-
-        let (uuid, mut file) = index_scheduler.create_update_file_with_uuid(0).unwrap();
-        let documents_count = read_json(content.as_bytes(), file.as_file_mut()).unwrap();
-        file.persist().unwrap();
-        index_scheduler
-            .register(KindWithContent::DocumentAdditionOrUpdate {
-                index_uid: S("doggos"),
-                primary_key: Some(S("id")),
-                method: ReplaceDocuments,
-                content_file: uuid,
-                documents_count,
-                allow_index_creation: true,
-            })
-            .unwrap();
-        snapshot!(snapshot_index_scheduler(&index_scheduler), name: "registered_the_second_task");
-
-        // The deletion should have failed because it can't create an index
-        handle.advance_one_failed_batch();
-        snapshot!(snapshot_index_scheduler(&index_scheduler), name: "after_failing_the_deletion");
-
-        // The addition should works
-        handle.advance_one_successful_batch();
-        snapshot!(snapshot_index_scheduler(&index_scheduler), name: "after_last_successful_addition");
-
-        let index = index_scheduler.index("doggos").unwrap();
-        let rtxn = index.read_txn().unwrap();
-        let field_ids_map = index.fields_ids_map(&rtxn).unwrap();
-        let field_ids = field_ids_map.ids().collect::<Vec<_>>();
-        let documents = index
-            .all_documents(&rtxn)
-            .unwrap()
-            .map(|ret| obkv_to_json(&field_ids, &field_ids_map, ret.unwrap().1).unwrap())
-            .collect::<Vec<_>>();
-        snapshot!(serde_json::to_string_pretty(&documents).unwrap(), name: "documents");
-    }
-
     #[test]
     fn do_not_batch_task_of_different_indexes() {
         let (index_scheduler, mut handle) = IndexScheduler::test(true, vec![]);